Appealing a marking decision
If your assessment hasn’t passed and you believe our marking decision is wrong, you can appeal. This page explains who can appeal, the time limit, how we handle an appeal and how to send it with your evidence.
Our marking decisions
Whether our assessor applied the published requirements (the NCSC’s Cyber Essentials Requirements for IT Infrastructure) and IASME’s marking guidance correctly to the answers and evidence in your submission, on an assessment we certify: Cyber Essentials (Self-led or Supported Certification) or IASME Cyber Assurance.
The applicant
The organisation being certified, through someone who works for it and is authorised to act for it. MSPs and other third parties can’t lodge an appeal on an applicant’s behalf, but your IT provider can help you prepare your evidence.
Within 3 days
Lodge your appeal within 3 days of receiving the decision you’re appealing. Keep copies of all the documents to do with your assessment and your appeal.
What an appeal can and can’t cover
An appeal can cover a marking decision where you believe the assessor misread or misapplied the published requirements or IASME’s marking guidance to the answers and evidence you submitted, as they stood when the decision was made.
The published requirements are the NCSC’s Cyber Essentials: Requirements for IT Infrastructure v3.3, not the articles in our Resource Hub, which are general guidance. IASME’s marking guidance means both IASME’s documented marking guidance and the marking recommendations discussed at IASME’s monthly certification body assessor meetings. It’s confidential to IASME-licensed assessors, so we can’t publish it or share it, but our review will explain the reasoning behind the marking.
An appeal can’t cover:
- The requirements themselves, or IASME’s marking guidance. These are set by the NCSC and IASME, not by us. If you disagree with a requirement, you can raise it with IASME.
- Changes made after the decision. Fixes, new settings or new evidence of controls put in place after your assessment was marked can’t change that result. They need a new assessment, which is charged separately.
- The results or use of our free tools. See the note below.
Cyber Essentials Plus audits are carried out by an IASME-licensed CE+ assessor under their certification body, so a CE+ audit decision is appealed through that certification body. Your CE+ assessor will explain how.
How we handle an appeal
- Stage 1: we review it, once. We log your appeal and acknowledge it within 5 working days, and aim to reply in full within 20 working days. Where we can, a different assessor reviews the disputed decision. We’ll explain the reasoning behind the marking and, where needed, liaise with you and with the assessor or IASME moderator involved to try to resolve it.
- Stage 2: IASME. If you’re still not satisfied with our review, the appeal can only go further through IASME, which runs the Cyber Essentials scheme for the NCSC and licenses us. We’ll email IASME the details with you copied in, or you can write to IASME directly. We don’t carry out a second review ourselves. IASME acknowledges an appeal within 2 working days, and its complaints and appeals process then applies. IASME’s decision on the certification outcome is final as far as the scheme is concerned.
Appeal fee
There’s a fee to lodge an appeal, from £235 + VAT depending on the size of your organisation. It’s refunded in full if we uphold your appeal. If we don’t, the fee isn’t refundable. Pay the fee first, then lodge your appeal with your order number, all within the 3-day time limit. Additional evidence for an appeal you’ve already lodged is free.
Our terms of business (section 15) include this process, and you accept it when you buy Self-led or Supported Certification.
Why you need a website account
Appeals can only be lodged by a signed-in member, so every appeal is logged against a website account. This gives you and us a clear audit trail:
- a unique appeal reference, with the date and time it was logged and the account that sent it;
- a record of what you told us, the declarations you accepted and every evidence file you sent;
- every change of status, so you can see where your appeal is at any time;
- once it’s logged, you can add evidence but can’t change or delete the record, and nor can anyone else outside our team.
An account is free. If you can, create it with the email address you use for your assessment. You’ll see your appeals under My appeals in your account, and you can add more evidence there at any time.
Appeals based on our free tools won’t be accepted
Our complimentary tools, including the readiness self-check, version checker, password checker, email security check and members’ tools, are offered for information and as an aid to help you prepare. They’re not a way to guarantee a pass. In summary, our free tools terms say that:
- the tools are guidance only, not an assessment, pre-check or advice, and they play no part in deciding your certification: only the assessor’s marking does;
- a tool result, or how you used a tool, isn’t grounds for an appeal, a refund or re-mark, a guarantee claim or a deadline extension, even if a tool showed no gaps or turned out to be wrong;
- the tools are provided “as is”. The NCSC requirements and IASME’s marking guidance change often and the tools aren’t updated in line with every change, so they may contain errors. As far as the law allows, we’re not responsible for any errors or for any loss from using the tools, and you use them on that understanding.
Spotted an error in a tool? Please tell us as soon as possible at team@getcybercertified.co.uk, or use the Suggest a feature or report a bug button at the foot of the tool, so we can look at fixing it in a future version. Reporting an error doesn’t change the outcome of an assessment.
Lodge an appeal
Sign in to lodge an appeal
So that your appeal is logged against your account, please sign in or create a free account first. You’ll come straight back here.
Your appeals
Signed in as . This appeal will be logged against this account.
Thank you. Your appeal has been logged.
Your reference is . We’ll acknowledge it within 5 working days. You can see it, and add more evidence, under My appeals in your account.
Having trouble with the form? Call 0333 339 0383 or email team@getcybercertified.co.uk and we’ll help you get your appeal logged.